Getting desperate???
(photo taken at the Gum Wall in Seattle, WA)
(photo taken at the Gum Wall in Seattle, WA)
What are you looking for in a carving medium? Simple question, it would seem.
Even if we don't always stop to consider our expectations, they are still there.
They exist as we first run our hand across the surface of the material.
They are in our hands and our minds as we begin creating lines and curves, alternately discarding and retaining the material as we do.
They are present when we ink up and when we stamp down.
Expectations.
So, what am I looking for in a carving medium? I've got a list of answers to my question, and I wrote four pages that would have drowned any hapless reader in my thoughts -- but I slept on it before posting. That was a good thing. Instead of publishing the tome, I have attempted to distill my ideas into one conclusion, and it is this:
Every other expectation, however important, seems to pale when I consider that one core thought.
Recently, I was asked to try three new carving materials (ECO, Smooth-Cut, and Karve Majik) to see how well they performed with my carving needle. Here are my brief thoughts:
1. The Karve Majik had to be abandoned pretty quickly for me. Instead of cleanly slicing the material, my (very sharp) needle pushed the material into tiny, gummy hills which eventually gave to the pressure of the needle with unpredictable results. Very frustrating.
2. Smooth-Cut and ECO, while different in many other respects, were the same in the one way that mattered to me most: Their grainy consistency made it impossible for me to get absolutely smooth cuts with my needle. This doesn't make as big a difference with a large, bold image as it does with a detailed one, and I enjoy the challenge of creating a fairly detailed image.
Here is the bottom line for me: The best images that I could produce with these materials looked like I had carved them two years ago. I'm not the most skilled carver among us, that's for sure -- I don't pretend to be. When I draw conclusions, I'm not comparing my work or my expectations to that of anyone else. I just don't want to be forced back to an earlier level of skill and left there.
Period.
Even if we don't always stop to consider our expectations, they are still there.
They exist as we first run our hand across the surface of the material.
They are in our hands and our minds as we begin creating lines and curves, alternately discarding and retaining the material as we do.
They are present when we ink up and when we stamp down.
Expectations.
So, what am I looking for in a carving medium? I've got a list of answers to my question, and I wrote four pages that would have drowned any hapless reader in my thoughts -- but I slept on it before posting. That was a good thing. Instead of publishing the tome, I have attempted to distill my ideas into one conclusion, and it is this:
I want a carving material that will allow me to improve across time, until I've reached the limits of what I can produce as a carver. When I have reached that point, I want it to be because of my own limited skill, not because of the materials that I use.
Every other expectation, however important, seems to pale when I consider that one core thought.
Recently, I was asked to try three new carving materials (ECO, Smooth-Cut, and Karve Majik) to see how well they performed with my carving needle. Here are my brief thoughts:
1. The Karve Majik had to be abandoned pretty quickly for me. Instead of cleanly slicing the material, my (very sharp) needle pushed the material into tiny, gummy hills which eventually gave to the pressure of the needle with unpredictable results. Very frustrating.
2. Smooth-Cut and ECO, while different in many other respects, were the same in the one way that mattered to me most: Their grainy consistency made it impossible for me to get absolutely smooth cuts with my needle. This doesn't make as big a difference with a large, bold image as it does with a detailed one, and I enjoy the challenge of creating a fairly detailed image.
Here is the bottom line for me: The best images that I could produce with these materials looked like I had carved them two years ago. I'm not the most skilled carver among us, that's for sure -- I don't pretend to be. When I draw conclusions, I'm not comparing my work or my expectations to that of anyone else. I just don't want to be forced back to an earlier level of skill and left there.
Period.
I appreciate your thoughts and opinions on these carving materials. I definitely consider you one of the best needle carvers in in the country, so when you say the material doesn't meet expectations, I take heed. Thank you.
ReplyDeleteThanks for sharing your opinion - we came to the same conclusions, I see. I'm sure glad PZ is being restored to us soon. :o)
ReplyDeleteHear, Hear!
ReplyDelete